Skip to Content

Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu 2023

There is no better place than Jersey Mike’s Subs to grab a delicious lunch when you are in the mood for something quick and easy. Occasionally, however, it might be a good idea to shake things up a bit. That’s why secret menus are a great idea! Listed below are some of the most popular items on Jersey Mike’s secret menu, some of our favorites, as well as a few more ways you can customize your sandwich to make it your own!

It is important to note that some of the items in these secret menu offerings are subject to location-specific availability. Additionally, some of the offerings are not known by name to employees, so it is important to ask specifically for these customizations.

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu

Secret Menu Items

The Meateor

For meat lovers, this is the perfect sandwich! Taking a bite of one of these tasty subs will put you in a carnivore heaven, since they will have 8 types of meat inside. You can also include your choice of veggies, cheese and sauces to make your meal even better!

To order, ask for a sub of any size with turkey, bacon, salami, pepperoni, ham, roast beef, capicola, and prosciutto and any veggies or sauces you would like.

Jersey Mike’s Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo

As a twist on one of their classic offerings, this offering combines their cheese steak with just the right amount of kick so that you’ll never get tired of it.

There is no complicated order process for this one, as all you need to do is ask for their Big Kahuna Cheese Steak that is served with chipotle mayo on top.

Sub In A Tub

In spite of the fact that it is more of a hack than it is a secret menu item, this is still a great option for anyone who is watching their carb intake.

It is possible to order any Jersey Mike’s offering like this by asking them to put it in a tub whenever you place an order. This works best with cold subs but many customers have said they will also do this for hot subs.

R&R Special

There is a special twist to the R&R special that makes it a delicious update on a Reuben sandwich. Since Jersey Mike’s does not offer rye bread, this sandwich is offered on white, wheat, gluten free bread, or rosemary parmesan.

Many customers do say that this item is orderable by name, but if your local shop does not recognize it, the ingredients are sliced pastrami or corned beef, coleslaw, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing.

Surf ‘n’ Turf

Jersey Mike’s Surf and Turf may not be first on your mind when you think of subs, but this one is a unique take on the classic combination. This is the perfect option for when you want to try something new!

To order this, ask for a club supreme (#9) with swiss cheese substituted in place of the provolone, omit the bacon, and swap out the turkey for tuna.

Sweet Pepper Wrap

There is no better choice than this if you are looking for a vegetarian option or if you just want something lighter without having to give up carbs completely.

If you want this wrap, ask for grilled sweet bell peppers, tomato, lettuce, white onions, white American cheese, cherry pepper relish, and spicy chipotle mayo in a wrap.

Cafeteria Classic

The simplistic secret menu offering is perfect for anyone who wants a small taste of one of their childhood favorites! As a parent, you may also find this to be a great option when you’re bringing your kids out to eat as well.

To order this, ask for the #3 (Ham & Provolone), swap in swiss for provolone, and add your favorite toppings before asking for it to be heated. (Note: for toppings like lettuce, tomatoes, and cucumbers, it’s best to request these after the sandwich has been heated)

Cuban Supreme

There’s nothing better than a good Cuban sandwich, and this secret menu item is a perfect take on one. This sandwich can be ordered either cold or heated.

To order this, ask for the #5 (the super sub) and swap the swiss for provolone, the salami for cappacuolo, and add pickles and spicy mustard.


For a sandwich that is out of this world, the Martian sub is perfect! Featuring a variety of meats and your choice of veggies, this sub is an excellent pick-me-up.

This is another option that many workers will know by name, but on the chance that they don’t, you can order this by asking for the #5 (the super sub), swapping out the ham for salami, and pepperoni in place of prosciuttini. Hot peppers are a very popular addition to this one.

The Chicka-Phila-Roni

First introduced in 2011, the Chicka-Phila-Roni is a unique take on a Philly Cheese Steak. With a generous amount of chicken, pepperoni, and plenty of cheese, this is one of the most delicious options that you can still get from the secret menu.

To order this, ask for a Mike’s Famous Philly, sub the steak for breaded chicken, and adding pepperoni and chipotle mayo. Note that this one is only available at locations that have breaded chicken.

Philly Cheese Steak with Roast Beef

Jersey Mike’s Philly Cheese Steak is called “Philly Beef” and it’s not considered steak, Tri-Tip nor 100% beef as it includes other ingredients such as water, dextrose and salt.

To order a Philly Cheese Steak with freshly sliced 100% certified Angus beef ask for roast beef instead of Philly Beef. Jersey Mike’s will slice the roast beef and grill it right there in front of you.

Jersey Mike’s Philly Beef Ingredients: Beef containing solution of water, dextrose, salt, potassium lactate, sodium phosphate, natural flavors.

Greek Grilled Chicken Salad

There is nothing better than a refreshing bite of Greek chicken salad for a lunch alternative. This is one of the items that you will get in the aforementioned tub style.

To order this, ask for the chicken caesar wrap in a tub, ask for it Mike’s Way, and omit the caesar dressing.

Lumberjack Salad

The Lumberjack salad is the perfect salad for when you want something hearty and filling that you won’t be able to put down! This salad is incredibly meat focused with smoked bacon, roast beef, and turkey!

To order the Lumberjack salad, ask for the #9 (club supreme) in a tub, and add spicy mustard on top.

Online Menu Items

While it’s reported that these items typically aren’t on Jersey Mike’s in person menu, these are options that are available to order from your phone or computer.

The BLT from Jersey Mike’s

Classics are always a reliable option from any sandwich shop, and Jersey Mike’s is no exception. You can customize this sub to your heart’s content with many of the options listed below.

The Cancro Special

*This one is on the regular menu at the time of this writing

The Cancro special is a staple of Jersey Mike’s history. With delicious oven roasted top rounds and pepperoni, topped with provolone makes this the perfect sandwich for a lunch stop. One recommended adjustment to this is to swap the white bread for rosemary parmesan!

California Club

If you would like something fresh for lunch, the California Club sub is the perfect option for you! With avocado, bacon, turkey, and provolone this a delicious sub. If you want to add an extra delicious touch, the cherry pepper relish is the way to go!

Customization Options

If you do not choose any of the amazing options above, there are still so many ways for you to customize your sub to your heart’s content.

Meat available at most locations:

Bacon, ham, cappacuolo, prosciuttini, turkey, tuna, roast beef, salami, pepperoni, steak, chicken

Available Sauces to add to any sub:

Red Wine Vinegar, Olive Oil Blend, Cherry Pepper Relish, Yellow Mustard, Honey Mustard, Mayo, Frank’s Red Hot

Size Options:

Mini (5 inch), Regular (7 inch, Giant (14-15 inch), Wrap, Bowl

Bread Options:

Rosemary Parmesan Bread, Gluten Free, White, Wheat


Portabella mushrooms, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Oregano, Salt, Dill Pickles, Banana Peppers, Jalapeño Peppers

What Else Does Jersey Mike’s Offer?

Chips, fountain drinks, and cookies and brownies are available at Jersey Mike’s.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Mike’s Way at Jersey Mikes?
Mike’s Way is a sub made with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices. You can also customize Mike’s Way by adding, excluding or substituting ingredients.

What kind of beef is used in Jersey Mike’s Philly Cheese Steak?
Jersey Mike’s uses a beef that they call “Philly Beef” which contains beef and a solution of water, dextrose, salt, potassium lactate, sodium phosphate, natural flavors.

What kind of oil and vinegar does Jersey Mike’s use?
Jersey Mike’s uses red wine vinegar that is reduced with water to 5% acidity and an olive oil blend which is a combination of vegetable oil (canola and/or soybean oil) and olive oil.

How big is a Jersey Mike’s mini sub?
A mini sub is 5 inches long.

How big is a Jersey Mike’s regular sub?
A regular sub is 7 inches long.

How big is a Jersey Mike’s giant sub?
A giant sub is 14-15 inches long.

Does Jersey Mike’s have salads?
Jersey Mike’s does not serve salads.

Is Jersey Mike’s open on holidays?
Jersey Mike’s stores are closed on Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day. All other holiday operating hours vary by location.

Does Jersey Mike’s serve breakfast?
Jersey Mike’s does not have breakfast sandwiches.

What time does Jersey Mike’s open?
Most locations open at 10AM, but operating hours vary by location.

What time does Jersey Mike’s close?
Most locations close at 9PM but operating hours vary by location.

Is there a Jersey Mike’s App?
Yes, Jersey Mike’s has an app. It is available for both iPhone and Android.

Can you order Jersey Mike’s online?
Yes, you can order online through the app, or through their website at Create a MyMike’s account to receive offers, earn rewards, and more. You can also order Jersey Mike;s through delivery services like Uber Eats and Door Dash.

Does Jersey Mike’s have gift cards?
Yes, Jersey Mike’s has physical and digital gift cards available for purchase.

Does Jersey Mike’s serve Pepsi or Coke products?
Jersey Mike’s serves Pepsi products, plus a few bottled and canned products like Gatorade, Pure Leaf Tea, and Aquafina.

Does Jersey Mike’s have Wi-Fi?
Wi-Fi availability may vary by location, but many locations do not have free wi-fi.

When was Jersey Mike’s Founded?
Jersey Mike’s was founded in 1956 at the Jersey Shore in Point Pleasant, New Jersey.

Where was the original Jersey Mike’s store located?
Jersey Mike’s first started in Point Pleasant, New Jersey. The former address was 1009 Trenton Avenue, Point Pleasant, New Jersey.

Is the original Jersey Mike’s still open?
The original store is no longer open to the public as it has become the National Training Center. Their flagship location is located nearby at 901 Richmond Avenue.

Who owns Jersey Mike’s?
Peter Cancro is the CEO/Owner of Jersey Mike’s.

Find More Secret Menus In Orange County

Related Articles

Wendy’s Secret MenuShake Shack Secret Menu
Chipotle Secret MenuMcDonald’s Secret Menu
Chick-fil-A Secret MenuDel Taco Secret Menu

Morgan Mulac is a freelance writer who has spent years on the road as a nomad and now has settled back in California with her family. Some of her favorite spots to travel to in California are in Orange County and the many beaches along the coast. She’s an avid writer about her journeys and enjoys sharing the beauty California has to offer.